Gaster

no it was mettaton she says so in her fight

i know

Hmmmmm
Makes sense I guess

i mean if you listen to spider dance you can hear dark, darker, yet darker

Yeah
And muffet says they saw the person changing shape in the shadows
And gaster was shattered into pieces so he could perhaps change shape

I hear ghost fight tho so it could be one of the blooks

Oh yeah that too.

Just remember.
Pathetic House, Ghost Fight, Dummy!, Spider Dance, and Mad Mew Mew all use the same base track.

She also said the person had a sweet smile, and I doubt Gaster's smile qualifies as sweet.

Hmm. Wait. If you look at the character model of what we believe is gaster, his smile isn't necessarily the thing that is unwelcoming and creepy about him. Its the cracks and his eyes that make him look so freaky. His smile may be the sweetest part of his face. She only mentions The smile being nice, but not anything else.

hmmmmmm

I'm actually more disturbed by the smile than any other part of Gaster's face.

Must be just me then.

no, you may have a point

Yep

and the sound that plays when you touch mysteryman in the secret waterfall room is a reversed and distorted version of muffet's laugh

and where did you get that from?

matpat, duh

-_- you do know that's a theory right? and that some of the vids he made on underrtale were jokes right?

the theory parts were about how and if muffet is related to gaster, but that is one of the FACTS he used to support his theory

and how is a "nonesixtnst man" Related to a Spider I ask you?

That doesn't support his theory.
Toby Fox just reused sound files in Undertale.
Spider Dance is a remix of Dummy, but that doesn't mean Muffet and Mad Dummy are related.

but it's still a fact, and the actual post is a theory

what did you just 2 hours ago "the theory parts were about how and if Muffet is related to gaster, but that is one of the FACTS he used to support his theory"

I don't understand the point of your 'what did you just'.

It was supposed to be what did you just say and it's supposed to emphasize that you went back on your point

what do you not understand

That's not evidence.
Spider Dance is a remix of Dummy!, but that doesn't mean anything.

You said because one song is a remix of a dummy that means that a spider is related to a non-existent man and then you said that was false or you don't know how to spell

I said that a song being reused ISN'T proof that the two characters are related.
That's all I said.

Hmm, you know what? you can have your Opinion and I can have mine