It is a good idea but likely wouldn't work. I'm just going to give people I like 4 stars on ever meme they make to bump it up the board anyway. So we would still be in the same situation before long.
I mean like, say 400 people kind of like meme A, and upvote it.
Then 100 people really like meme B, and upvote it. B then should give the creator more points, and get featured more often.
I definitely like the idea. I just don't know that it would work.
Too many mediocre memes top the charts because they are made by famous memers with a Facebook following. They would still get a million stars and we would still be right here.
If this meme (which took 9 seconds to make) was uploaded by TrustyGoat or one of the cool guys it would still get 75 upvotes or a 300 stars, even though it stinks. I'm just saying.