A lot of subtle things going on here; see if your can spot them all.

The pie is bleeding. Creature under counter. Woman has tentacles. Dude has tenticals. Bloody hand print. Tentical on the floor. Skull in coffee. Guy has scars on his neck.

Answers can be found at https://imgflip.com/i/29hxk2

FWIW, those aren't scars but gills

I was close.

I'm surprised everyone missed the ridiculously low prices.

It doesn’t look like anyone tried.

not the only place I posted it. Personal friends and family love these sort of things.