Sorry, went through the page of your latest featured memes and only found a few worth upvoting. Most lacked entertainment value. True, the had smarmy punchlines but no set up. You really need to work on what makes a meme entertaining. The Ice Soup meme was great: it was actually funny. That one actually played to a world audience and deserved at least page 3. Page 1 is determined by how entertaining a meme is, and how well it strikes the right chord with other users.
This one, https://i.imgflip.com/28mi83.jpg thought about it, and decided it could use an upvote. One reason it did so poorly is you missed the opportunity to add the "WHY NOT BOTH" with it: either tacking that meme on the bottom of yours or using the phrase in the title.
Instead of begging for upvotes, you need to earn them, and more than you will upvote whoring. Yes, many of us, myself included, will beg for upvotes, but the people you see on the weekly leaderboard, and those on the all time top poster list, rely on entertaining the public at large.