It makes no sense...

I'm in the same boat. I think it has to do with how many views, upvotes and comments you have in a set period of time.

Just persevere. By the numbers, you're on the right track. Look at the memes that did well. It's disappointing when you don't get there, but one day, along the way, you'll make it. Right now, my goal is to close in and make the leaderboard. I've only had on meme that made it to front page, several that were at or near the top of page two, a ton on page three. Just keep a positive attitude. I started from scratch in November, and I'm closing in on my goal.

Yeah I don't really care much about points and making the front page etc. I just make memes because I enjoy it and hope a few others will enjoy them. It's just hilarious to see memes with 60 views and 8 upvotes way atop ones that have 1,000 views and 30 upvotes etc.

Haven't seen it that bad on front page. I thought I might make it last week with my von Drake meme, but it stayed on page three a while, moved to page two, then back to three. It was on those pages like 4 days. Took most of that time to break 1000. I think the lowest views I've seen on page one was still over 600, but the meme was still in the "made x hours ago" phase. That's hours, not days.