Yes I know I have had one, but there are some users that every day have at least 1 new one (and not all are even that good)

Being a popular user doesn't guarantee front page memes... and "getting a meme to the front page that isn't even that good" is something that can happen for all users, not just popular ones. You never know what's going to make the front page.

I can guarantee that there are certain users that could repost most of my memes and just because of their status it would be on the front page. There was a set of 3 meme addiction memes that you thought either one would have made the front page, and at the time they didn't even have 10 votes. So you can't say quality wasn't there, which means what lacked was popularity.