(cont. 2) and entangled in secret phone calls) and Ralsei being Asriel in disguise, Susie becomes the only genuine, uncompromised hero of the Prophecy. That explains why she has no hidden strings, why Gerson singles her out in Chapter 4 with the “White Pen” speech about shaping how the story ends, and why Ralsei works so hard to shield her from the darker parts of the Prophecy.
Lancer Is the Real “Prince from the Dark”: Lancer actually checks every literal box of the Prophecy—he is an authentic Darkner, genuine royalty, Susie's best friend, and functions as an unofficial fourth party member. The two real Prophecy heroes (Susie and Lancer) naturally bonded on day one without Asriel orchestrating it.
Carol, Dess, and the Motive for the Roaring: Chapter 4's Gerson “Dustner” rule (scattering a monster's dust on a cherished object revives them inside a Dark World, though they vanish if the fountain closes) explains why Carol wants to trigger the Roaring. Dess died during the incident at the lake behind Asgore's flower shop, and her dust rests on an object in her locked-down room; permanently merging Light and Dark through the Roaring is Carol's only way to keep Dess alive forever.
The Knight Connection: Whether Carol is the Knight directly (matching the three-pronged antlers, katanas, guitar hand-switching, freezing touch/north wind text, sparing Kris, and kidnapping Undyne and Asgore) or collaborating with a corrupted, Dustner-like Dess (matching the wiffle-bat “Black Knife,” black fluid/body horror, red-text phone calls, and Chapter 4 church timing), Asriel's covert mission is to steer Kris away from Carol's Roaring endgame and protect them from the SOUL.(yes i had an ai summarize my theory, it's because it was in too many peices and i couldnt organize it myself-)